Redcrab's server
-
- Member
- Posts: 4290
- Joined: Sun Sep 09, 2012 17:31
- GitHub: Sokomine
- IRC: Sokomine
- In-game: Sokomine
Seeing griefed houses is always sad. But still, griefers may learn and behave better in the future. At least some may.
Maybe there is a third solution to the problem with the griefers. The area protection allows to dig and place nodes on ground where one has the permission to do so and on land that is not owned. How if that was changed for griefers? They could be "granted" a special priv like "rehabilitation" and be forbidden to build/dig on *unprotected* land - while still beeing able to build on their own areas. Granted, this might make life more difficult for them, but they *did* cause other people (especially cactuz) to waste time with them. This way, they can still prove that they've changed - by investing time in a very good building that would be lost due to rollback if they griefed again.
That solution would require changes to the mod that does the protection. At least that would have to be done just once. Finding out if previous griefers did improve their behaviour and did construct something of value in the meantime and thus can regain full privileges (or loose the limiting priv) will take time.
Maybe there is a third solution to the problem with the griefers. The area protection allows to dig and place nodes on ground where one has the permission to do so and on land that is not owned. How if that was changed for griefers? They could be "granted" a special priv like "rehabilitation" and be forbidden to build/dig on *unprotected* land - while still beeing able to build on their own areas. Granted, this might make life more difficult for them, but they *did* cause other people (especially cactuz) to waste time with them. This way, they can still prove that they've changed - by investing time in a very good building that would be lost due to rollback if they griefed again.
That solution would require changes to the mod that does the protection. At least that would have to be done just once. Finding out if previous griefers did improve their behaviour and did construct something of value in the meantime and thus can regain full privileges (or loose the limiting priv) will take time.
A list of my mods can be found here.
... and requires the intervention of redcrab.Sokomine wrote:That solution would require changes to the mod that does the protection.
As you said rollback is punishment in itself, we can add to this 3 days without "interact" and ban only most annoying greifers (after 3 rollbacks, for example).
Last edited by cactuz_pl on Tue Jan 01, 2013 16:51, edited 1 time in total.
Nope
Cactuz, I may not be able to vote in-game like you suggested we do, I'm very busy at times. Usually I only have time to check the forums. But I vote for No mercy law. Happy New Year!
Taking a break for a while see ya guys!
In some of my posts I will be putting "Secret" White sentences.. Tell me if you see them!!!
In some of my posts I will be putting "Secret" White sentences.. Tell me if you see them!!!
Voting was only concept.davidpace wrote:Cactuz, I may not be able to vote in-game like you suggested we do, I'm very busy at times. Usually I only have time to check the forums. But I vote for No mercy law. Happy New Year!
Sokomone's idea is better than No mercy law, destroying greifer's work is good punishment.
Nope
- Obiewan1111
- Member
- Posts: 198
- Joined: Fri Dec 14, 2012 20:30
- Location: Salisbury, Wiltshire, England
It was Randy all along. D:Nexdah wrote:HELLO_IM_DEATH Was griefing my mansion When I was doing some Improvements. Please protect my area now!
Youtube Channel; Minetest Gaming Videos
Is suggesting the Offtopic Section and getting it added an achievement? I guess it is!
Is suggesting the Offtopic Section and getting it added an achievement? I guess it is!
- HELLO_IM_DEATH
- Member
- Posts: 55
- Joined: Mon Dec 17, 2012 21:15
I think HELLO_IM_DEATH should be perma banned now! Nexdah if you didn't fix up your mansion yet, DO NOT TOUCH IT!
Cactuz needs proof of the grief, he will use rollbackcheck, do not touch your mansion if you want to get rid of griefers such as HELLO_IM_DEATH!!!!
Cactuz needs proof of the grief, he will use rollbackcheck, do not touch your mansion if you want to get rid of griefers such as HELLO_IM_DEATH!!!!
Taking a break for a while see ya guys!
In some of my posts I will be putting "Secret" White sentences.. Tell me if you see them!!!
In some of my posts I will be putting "Secret" White sentences.. Tell me if you see them!!!
- Obiewan1111
- Member
- Posts: 198
- Joined: Fri Dec 14, 2012 20:30
- Location: Salisbury, Wiltshire, England
Isn't there an equivalent to logs? Or logs itself? He could just check them, am I wrong?
Youtube Channel; Minetest Gaming Videos
Is suggesting the Offtopic Section and getting it added an achievement? I guess it is!
Is suggesting the Offtopic Section and getting it added an achievement? I guess it is!
- AspireMint
- Member
- Posts: 415
- Joined: Mon Jul 09, 2012 12:59
- GitHub: AspireMint
- IRC: AspireMint
- In-game: AspireMint
- Location: Stuck at spawn
Hello, i vote for my idea ^^
but i will agree with your decision1. build school <--- spawn
2. destroy abandoned houses at spawn (more areas for new players)
or rebuild + protect
3. rebuild important/rich(superglowglass:D) roads + protect
4. no mercy law because of 1. point
"Truth hurts. Maybe not as much as jumping on a bicycle with the seat missing, but it hurts."
"There's 🧁for you, 🧁for me, 🧁for sale, 🧁for free"
"I came here to drink milk and kick ass, and I've just finished my milk!" ― Maurice Moss
"There's 🧁for you, 🧁for me, 🧁for sale, 🧁for free"
"I came here to drink milk and kick ass, and I've just finished my milk!" ― Maurice Moss
If I_AM_DEATH griefed ban him Nexdah could you explain what he was doing
I_AM_DEATH can you explain what you were doing there?
I_AM_DEATH can you explain what you were doing there?
Sometimes, it's harder to think up a mod than it is to create it.
Mods: Orichalcum Stonebricks Extra Chests
Mods: Orichalcum Stonebricks Extra Chests
-
- Member
- Posts: 113
- Joined: Sun Apr 22, 2012 18:22
Even if he doesn't have access to the logs it seems that Cactuz is able to see the last person to interact with specific nodes, which is why people are advised not to do repairs until he's had a chance to see the griefed area.davidpace wrote:I don't think redcrab is online much, I dunno if he is seeing this.. And I doubt cactuzPL can check...
Pkmn White 2 FC: 4213-1790-7873
Here's some pictures of the destruction of my sky mansion and dvx's lava property next to it. I'll be protecting my sky mansion as soon as I repair it, and I hope dvx protects his property soon because this is the second and worst time his lava has been used for ill.
I came home to find a giant, fugly wooden entrace all over my grand entrace, but I fixed it and most other major damage in a rage before I started snapping shots. Here's the stuff I got after wisening up.
The first photo here is of my glowglass column on the top floor, which has become an ugly path to the roof.
This is between my path and dvx's property. I just built that wall with the sign a few days ago because somebody else griefed in a much more minor manner, but this is much worse now.
Here's the sign changed to give whoever did it credit, which I discovered after clearing away the wood all over my entrance.
Every tree in and around my house (which were all sculpted in specific shapes) is gone.
Back on the ground with dvx's property, a canal has been dug and filled with lava, ruining many nearby paths. The lava flows underground into an undergrand lake that contains many of my mineshafts. I fixed it was best I could and got rid of the lava sources, but there's sitll damage all around.
I came home to find a giant, fugly wooden entrace all over my grand entrace, but I fixed it and most other major damage in a rage before I started snapping shots. Here's the stuff I got after wisening up.
The first photo here is of my glowglass column on the top floor, which has become an ugly path to the roof.
This is between my path and dvx's property. I just built that wall with the sign a few days ago because somebody else griefed in a much more minor manner, but this is much worse now.
Here's the sign changed to give whoever did it credit, which I discovered after clearing away the wood all over my entrance.
Every tree in and around my house (which were all sculpted in specific shapes) is gone.
Back on the ground with dvx's property, a canal has been dug and filled with lava, ruining many nearby paths. The lava flows underground into an undergrand lake that contains many of my mineshafts. I fixed it was best I could and got rid of the lava sources, but there's sitll damage all around.
Forever losing passwords...
- webdesigner97
- Member
- Posts: 1328
- Joined: Mon Jul 30, 2012 19:16
- GitHub: webD97
- IRC: webdesigner97
- In-game: webdesigner97
- Location: Cologne, Germany
- Contact:
Why do you post that twice? I don't think we need it.Leroy wrote:We need the Boats Mod!
Visit me: webD97.de | @GitHub | @DeviantArt
Mods: StreetsMod | Vehicles
Featured from my blog: Dockerize the Minetest server
On my own behalf: Chameleon - A PHP image manipulation library built around GD
Mods: StreetsMod | Vehicles
Featured from my blog: Dockerize the Minetest server
On my own behalf: Chameleon - A PHP image manipulation library built around GD
- webdesigner97
- Member
- Posts: 1328
- Joined: Mon Jul 30, 2012 19:16
- GitHub: webD97
- IRC: webdesigner97
- In-game: webdesigner97
- Location: Cologne, Germany
- Contact:
Is that true?
Visit me: webD97.de | @GitHub | @DeviantArt
Mods: StreetsMod | Vehicles
Featured from my blog: Dockerize the Minetest server
On my own behalf: Chameleon - A PHP image manipulation library built around GD
Mods: StreetsMod | Vehicles
Featured from my blog: Dockerize the Minetest server
On my own behalf: Chameleon - A PHP image manipulation library built around GD
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests