RIP Nyan Cats.

[bigfoot]

Nyan cats have to go. We have made their replacements: #1658. Let's all have a moment of silence for nyan cats. Please all say something profound about these pop-tart nodes that have made all of our lives better. Here is the video: Watch 4 ever!
Trademarks have ruined all of our lives.

[red-001]

Not copyright, trademarks. Not that it makes it any better.

[MineYoshi]

Well... Nyan Cats will always be in our hearts :^)

[BBmine]

Now I know why I called the nyan cats "Nyan puppies". And I didn't even know about this! I've been calling it that for a few months. XD

[sofar]

FTR

The nyan cat is trademarked. The trademark owner has asserted and defended their trademark when people used it for commercial purposes. They also stated that non-commercial use is OK.

Minetest_game is permissively licensed and (apart from the nyan cat) has no -non-commercial- parts.

This nyan cat prevents anyone from doing several things with minetest_game:

- asking people to pay for joining a server
- making a video and putting it on youtube with advertising to make some money for a server
- using minetest_game in a company that offers private tutoring to kids
- using minetest_game in any setting that is not a strict non-for-profit setting, like holding a LAN party in your office

We believe that minetest_game shouldn't restrict any of these uses, hence the removal.

(I won't discuss the details of the removal in this thread. How we remove it and whether we replace it should be a different discusion/thread).

[bigfoot]

Geez sofar, this was a joke you know. Not a legal document. :P

[sofar]

Geez sofar, this was a joke you know. Not a legal document. :P

gheghe I know. It's not bad to plainly explain what happened, though...

[stoneminer]

Goodbye, nyan cats...so sorry to see you go.

[Melkor]

im going to leave this here:

Vote for Grumpy cat!

[Jordach]

FTR

The nyan cat is trademarked. The trademark owner has asserted and defended their trademark when people used it for commercial purposes. They also stated that non-commercial use is OK.

Minetest_game is permissively licensed and (apart from the nyan cat) has no -non-commercial- parts.

This nyan cat prevents anyone from doing several things with minetest_game:

- asking people to pay for joining a server
- making a video and putting it on youtube with advertising to make some money for a server
- using minetest_game in a company that offers private tutoring to kids
- using minetest_game in any setting that is not a strict non-for-profit setting, like holding a LAN party in your office

We believe that minetest_game shouldn't restrict any of these uses, hence the removal.

(I won't discuss the details of the removal in this thread. How we remove it and whether we replace it should be a different discusion/thread).

But allow DMCA'ing those Chinese iOS clients....

[Leshinforge]

Never forget the iconic flying poptart kitty. :(

They'll be in our hearts.

[sofar]

But allow DMCA'ing those Chinese iOS clients....

No, you can only file DMCA requests for Copyright Violations, not trademark violations.

Ref: http://www.lexology.com/library/detail. ... 215ce60a6d

EDIT: upon reading your post again I think you may have meant "nyan cat in minetest would be relicensed to CC-BY-NC" which does in deed potentially allow a DMCA request, but without source code we can't prove that they took an older version. Plus the IOS clients are usually only Clients, not Servers, in which case the server artwork is irrelevant.

[TenPlus1]

For anyone interested here is PB&J Pup (redo) which contains the original Nyan Cat alongside the PB&J Pup and has both spawning in world by default... It uses the new 'pbj_pup_generate' setting to turn spawning on/off, has sounds removed (never liked those), candies removed so that rainbows are always in use and textures have been optimized: https://github.com/tenplus1/pbj_pup

[sofar]

For anyone interested here is PB&J Pup (redo) which contains the original Nyan Cat alongside the PB&J Pup and has both spawning in world by default... It uses the new 'pbj_pup_generate' setting to turn spawning on/off, has sounds removed (never liked those), candies removed so that rainbows are always in use and textures have been optimized: https://github.com/tenplus1/pbj_pup

I applaud people making alternatives available. Even if I really don't like those alternatives :)

[sorcerykid]

Afaik the Nyan Cat image itself is also protected by copyright. Whether it's enforced or not is a different question. But most artistic works (visual works, literary works, architectural works, musical works, and many others) are automatically protected by copyright in the U.S. for a designated period, depending on when the work was created, regardless of whether the artistic work is actually registered with the Copyright Office. The only exception is if the copyright is specifically waived by the author or licensed otherwise for certain uses.

[rubenwardy]

It was drawn from scratch, with apparently minimal referencing

[TumeniNodes]

<cough... cough... COUGH.>


as I said, keeps the rainbow
can have prizes
pot can be used for any number of uses after found
the pros are endless and outweigh any cons

who wants to help me create it? (it's gonna need a model and an api) I can do textures and "some" coding

<edit> just thought, someone could even create a Leprechaun mob which protects them, and you have to fight them to get the pot... and maybe you even win something else special for defeating the Leprechaun as well.

The ideas and possibilities are endless---ish

[twoelk]

<cough... cough... COUGH.>
...<snip>...
as I said, keeps the rainbow
...<snippity>...
who wants to help me create it? (it's gonna need a model and an api) I can do textures and "some" coding
...<snap>...

there have been other rainbow mods that might be of interest for a running start.

well actually only Basic Rainbow [rainbow] really does add rainbows and if you are fast enough you may even find a pot of gold. Don't know wether this works underground though

[TumeniNodes]

<cough... cough... COUGH.>
...<snip>...
as I said, keeps the rainbow
...<snippity>...
who wants to help me create it? (it's gonna need a model and an api) I can do textures and "some" coding
...<snap>...

there have been other rainbow mods that might be of interest for a running start.

well actually only Basic Rainbow [rainbow] really does add rainbows and if you are fast enough you may even find a pot of gold. Don't know wether this works underground though

hmmm, I'll check them out..
Ahhhh... the last one, by coincidence, might have some visual-info I have been needing regarding voxelmanip :D
Thanks

[cx384]

:(

[Melkor]

:(

This is a "nice" end guys, close this thread :D

[ABJ]

Who the hell is using nyan cat as a trademark?

[red-001]

Who the hell is using nyan cat as a trademark?

Christopher Torres

[ABJ]

Ah ok, then it's ok. I thought some big corp had enslaved the 'cat. Though I wasn't expecting him to be this harsh though.

[MineYoshi]

Ah ok, then it's ok. I thought some big corp had enslaved the 'cat. Though I wasn't expecting him to be this harsh though.

Well, the Nyan cat is just an internet meme. I don't see any reason that a big Company like Coke Cola or Microsoft would like to buy it...